Max Yuryev compares the Sony vs Fujifilm color science.
It’s a blind test, so you have to go through 10 frames, note on paper if you prefer camera A and B. Of course I did it, and it turns out I prefered Fujifilm in 80% of the cases.
The video frames from 1 to 4 are taken with standard picture profile, whereas from 5 to 10 he compares Eterna to a custom made picture profile.
Some general conclusions Max made, before we watch at the frames one by one:
- in harsh daylight, with light bouncing, the Sony got some heavy tint, but Fuji’s smart color science got rid of it
- Sony is usually more accurate, but you have to spend time to get rid of that tint
- Fujifilm got it figured out, and you don’t have to worry about color tint
- If you just want to shoot, and not spent time color grading, Fujifilm is great
We remind you that, as reported here, Fujifilm makes a distinction between metric color and memory color. Metric color is more realistic, whereas memory color is interpretation, it’s how your brain sees and remembers colors in a certain scene.
Certain Fujifilm film simulations are not ment to be accurate representation of real colors, but interpretations closer to how you remember those colors.
Other film simulations instead just have to give a unique vibe to the image, think at the vintage touch of the less saturated Classic Chrome for example, great for documentary photography, thanks to the “art of omission” that puts the story/content in the center, instead of colors.
Colors science is a crucial factor at Fujifilm, and we told you already that the engineer, who developed the original Velvia film, has also developed the digital Velvia film simulation.
And now back to the comparison:
- Max: Sony looks oversaturated, but Max likes it, so he’d go for Sony
- FujiRumors: I immeditaly voted for Fujifilm
- Max: Somewhere in the middle would be good. Sony looks more true to life, the Fuji looks more filmish
- FujiRumors: This was the toughest for me, and I agree, somewhere in the middle would be right. I voted Sony, because the water had more realistic color
- Max: Sony has a green cast, but he prefers it over Fujifilm. Skin is brighter on Sony
- FujiRumors: I voted Fujifilm
- Max: he absolultely prefers the Fujifilm. Fujifilm gets rid of tint on her face. Fuji skin tone looks so pleasing
- FujiRumors: Something went terribly wrong with Sony skin tones in that frame! I voted Fujifilm, and I think everybody will
- Max: he prefers the Sony, which has more saturation
- FujiRumors: I voted Fujifilm, but I knew I had to look for the flat Eterna profile, and went for the less saturated image
- Max: he prefers Sony, because the greens pops more
- FujiRumors: I knew the flatter greens was Eterna, but I voted Sony, since I liked the more neutral water on the Sony
- Max: he says the Fuji looks flat, and he’d chose the Fujifilm in this case
- FujiRumors: I voted Fuji, which sure, looks flatter, but that’s Eterna. And for video use, the unsaturated and flatter image might be overall more pleasing to watch
- Max: a lot of tint in the Sony. He’d give the color win to the Fujifilm
- FujiRumors: I immediately voted for Fujifilm
- Max: he’d go for Sony, the color of the T-shirt is more realistic
- FujiRumors: once I again, I saw Eterna, I voted Fujifilm
- Max: he prefers Fujifilm
- FujiRumors: Fujifilm, Eterna, that’s it